What's the Difference: Tile backerboard
HardieBacker, Durock, and DensShield each has characteristics that affect where it can be installed and how tile is placed on it
Backerboard panels provide a flat, firm base for the installation of tile. They are resistant to the effects of water exposure, including swelling, rot, and mold growth, and they can be used in fire-resistant assemblies. Each type of backerboard costs roughly the same and is available in similar dimensions at most lumberyards. However, each has characteristics that affect where it can be installed and how tile is placed on it.
Composition: HardieBacker is made of cellulose fibers that are layered with cement slurry and cured through high-pressure autoclaving. The boards are also infused with additives to inhibit mold growth.
Cost: $10.50 for 1/2-in.-thick 3-ft. by 5-ft. sheet
Weight: 2.6 lb. per sq. ft. (1/2 in. thick)
Mortar: Modified latex thinset should be used on HardieBacker. This type of thinset is more expensive than non-modified products and also sets up faster—a benefit when working with large, heavy tile.
Installation: HardieBacker is best cut with carbon-tipped sawblades or specialty cutting shears and fastened to studs or joists with 11/2-in. corrosion-resistant screws or nails.
Notes: HardieBacker has a smooth surface that allows the panel to be finished with products other than tile, including wallpaper and paint. This makes the panels useful for finished basements or garages that would benefit from the panels’ moisture protection.
Composition: Durock panels have an aggregated portland-cement core and are wrapped with a polymer-coated, glass-fiber mesh.
Cost: $11 for 1/2-in.- thick 3-ft. by 5-ft. sheet
Weight: 3 lb. per sq. ft. (1/2 in. thick)
Mortar: Tile can be set with modified latex thinset or nonmodified dry-set mortar. The latter is a less-expensive option with a longer working time.
Installation: Durock is best cut with carbon-tipped sawblades or specialty cutting shears and fastened to studs or joists with 11/2-in. corrosionresistant screws or nails.