Using Housewrap for Insulation Baffles - Fine Homebuilding

previous
  • Magazine Departments
    Magazine Departments
  • 7 Trim Carpentry Secrets
    7 Trim Carpentry Secrets
  • Remodeling Articles
    Remodeling Articles
  • 7 Smart Kitchen Solutions
    7 Smart Kitchen Solutions
  • All about Roofing
    All about Roofing
  • Pro Tool Rental. Learn More.
    Pro Tool Rental. Learn More.
  • 7 Small Bathroom Layouts
    7 Small Bathroom Layouts
  • Tips & Techniques for Painting
    Tips & Techniques for Painting
  • Master Carpenter Videos
    Master Carpenter Videos
  • Hot Water Now
    Hot Water Now
  • Design Inspiration
    Design Inspiration
  • 9 Concrete Countertops Ideas
    9 Concrete Countertops Ideas
  • Basement Remodeling Tips
    Basement Remodeling Tips
  • Classic Cabinets
    Classic Cabinets
  • Video: Install a Fence
    Video: Install a Fence
  • Clever daily tip in your inbox
    Clever daily tip in your inbox
  • Energy-Smart Details
    Energy-Smart Details
  • Custom Flooring Inspiration
    Custom Flooring Inspiration
  • Radiant Heat Comparison
    Radiant Heat Comparison
  • Video Series: Tile a Bathroom
    Video Series: Tile a Bathroom
  • Read FHB on Your iPad
    Read FHB on Your iPad
next

Breaktime Spotlight

Breaktime Spotlight


Using Housewrap for Insulation Baffles

comments (4) October 25th, 2012
ScottG Scott Gibson, contributing writer


A bargain-hunting builder searches for an alternative to commercially available insulation baffles for use in a cathedral ceiling

Building on a tight budget? That's a situation many of us have faced, and bwkwood is one of them. He's in the process of putting up an addition with as little cash outlay as possible. He's rounded up some bargain insulation and is now looking for a cheaper alternative to insulation baffles for a cathedral ceiling.

"The R19 kraft faced fiberglass for the ceilings and walls (1000 sf) cost me only $200," bwkwood writes in a post at the Breaktime Construction Techniques forum. "It is going to drive me crazy to spend another $200 for the plastic insulation baffles at Home Depot."

He's come up with an alternative. For only $30, he can buy a 9-ft. by 100-ft. roll of housewrap. His plan is to cut the housewrap into strips 16 in. to 18 in. wide and fit them into the rafter bays in place of commercially available baffles.

"This would certainly fill the role as an air barrier in my rafter bays," bwkwood says. "Does anyone out there have a nifty idea on how I could maintain a 1 1/2-in. vent chute between sheathing and house wrap? It needs to be simple, time effective and cost effective."

Bwkwood's quest for economy and performance is the subject of this month's Breaktime Spotlight.

Is housewrap really an air barrier?

The gap immediately below the sheathing would allow air to travel from soffit vents to a ridge vent, carrying away any moisture that worked its way up through the insulation. He hopes the housewrap works as an air barrier to reduce air infiltration (and unwanted moisture) into roof cavities while maintaining the performance of the insulation.

But would housewrap accomplish what bwkwood hopes? Opinions are divided.

"Housewrap is not an air barrier material and will give you virtually zero benefit if installed as you describe it," davidmeiland tells bwkwood.

"Housewrap is most definitely an air barrier," DanH replies.

"Air barrier is generally a rigid material...drywall, plywood, rigid foam, etc." says davidmeiland. "There are rolled and liquid applied materials that would also serve, but they're not under discussion here. If he staples Tyvek into his rafter bays, he'll be the first guy I heard of who ever did it. Total waste of time, IMO."

In fact, he adds, builders who are aiming for tight houses are giving up on housewrap as an air barrier, even when all seams are taped. "Air moves through it easily," he says.

Wrap is possible, but foam is better

PaulCP replies that while housewrap is cheap (and assuming it works as an air barrier), there's still a lot of labor involved in bwkwood's plan. If he's determined to use it, PaulCP suggests starting with bundles of lath 3/4 in. thick, 1 1/2 in. wide and 8 ft. long.

"Tape [the lath] down to a clean concrete floor every 16 in. or 24 in.," he says. "Each center will have a lath border on both sides. Unroll the paper over it and staple it down to each of the lath pieces every 6 in. Now, cut the centers between the lath pieces that are side by side. You will be left with a piece of paper with two lath strips that you can attach to the sides of the rafters."

PaulCP adds that the assembly will leak "unless you tape the paper well at the seams, and caulk or foam where the lath and rafters meet."

An alternative, PaulCP says, would be to use sheets of rigid foam insulation, cut scored on a tablesaw so it could be bent to form a chute.

"You use a tablesaw to rip a sheet in 16-in. or 24-in. wide strips (depending on your rafter spacing)," he writes. "Then you set your blade height at 7/8 in. if you are using 1-in. board, and run the fence at 3/4 in. from the blade.

"Now you will score both long sides on the same face. Here comes the trick: Fold them over. Now you have a wide flat chute that is spaced exactly 1 in. from whatever you press it against. You would use foam to seal the edges and the seams. This is the best solution as it is high R value and waterproof if sealed correctly."

Two other possibilities

Two other posts suggest other cheap alternatives to foam. Junkhound faced the same dilemma and also was unwilling to spend the money for foam baffles. His solution was to scavenge 1/4-in. plywood from old crates and attach it to lengths of 2x4 and 2x2 scrap.

DanH would wait a couple of weeks and take advantage of the political season.

"Wait until the second week in November, then collect all the corrugated plastic political signs you can lay your hands on," he says. "They can be stapled to 1x2s and screwed in place or just slit halfway through and folded along the edges to allow them to be stapled in place."

Not only will the signs be free, he adds, they also will be more durable than the foam.

Do small gaps really make a difference?

The discussion leaves bwkwood confident that housewrap could be used as an air barrier, but it raises another concern if he goes ahead with his plan to staple the housewrap into the rafter bays:

"Would the fact that there would not be a perfect seal (without caulking or foaming) be that big of an issue?" he asks. "We are told that insulation like fiberglass is susceptible to R-value degradation if cold air flows through it, but the very small cracks that would result from stapling the housewrap, are they enough to cause any significant loss of R value?"

In a word, replies PaulCP, yes.

"To act as a proper insulator, air needs to be still," he writes. "Otherwise, it keeps bumping into solid objects and transferring heat energy, which is what you DON'T want. Unconditioned air from outside that is washing the underside of your roof deck will pull and push air in and out of your insulated space, lessening its effectiveness. It will also allow new moisture into the insulation space and provide new opportunities for condensation, rot, and mold."

He adds that vent chutes are typically only used in area immediately over the exterior wall. They're not designed for installing in the full length of rafter bays in a cathedral ceiling.

 

 

 


posted in: insulation

Comments (4)

kxm1 kxm1 writes: t
The commentary discussion here that began with bwkwood's desire to "build a cheaper mousetrap" RE: attic ventilation is addressing the short term benefits of such a mousetrap only.
Consideration of the long term cost benefit has not been addressed.
Currently we are experiencing relatively slow energy cost increases but that can not be expected to be a reliable condition for the future.
Energy costs will continue to rise in the future and that fact should be the prime consideration for any discussion regarding insulation and air movement in attic spaces over conditioned living spaces.
The use of sprayed foam insulation ( closed cell polyurethane ) in today's energy conscious world is a no brainer. Sprayed foam insulation addresses all of the concerns raised in the discussion-and its use particularly addresses the overall benefit of cost in terms of future energy savings. Sprayed foam attic insulation is by far the best method of achieving air sealing against the attic space/conditioned space border.
I have not seen any comments posted that directly address the most important concern for maintaining the comfort level in the conditioned space which is air sealing. Sprayed foam insulation is the best way to achieve a maximum air sealing benefit while at the same time providing the highest insulation value available by common insulation methods.
Fiberglass insulation should not be used at all as it does not provide good air sealing characteristics when compared to blown cellulose or sprayed foam insulation.
The attic space will still require proper ventilation if sprayed foam insulation is used.
Getting back to bwkwood's original question about alternative methods of providing baffling over the exterior walls in the attic-this becomes a moot point for consideration with sprayed foam insulation. The very high R value per inch of sprayed foam insulation will mean that there will not need to be a thickness of insulation at the exterior wall area in the attic that will
impede air flow from the soffit until you require around R 70 (using 2 x 6 ceiling joist and rafter widths ).
Don't let the higher per square foot installation costs of sprayed foam insulation deter you from considering its use. Look at the advantages and research the long term cost savings benefits in detail and you will probably see that sprayed foam is the "better mouse trap"!
Posted: 7:21 am on January 24th

gbaune gbaune writes: I like the rigid insulation technique, excellent idea!!
Posted: 3:46 pm on February 22nd

brewstew brewstew writes: Certain housewraps, like Tyvek, are most certainly air barrier materials per ASTM standard testing for air barrier materials. The problem with using a housewrap in this application is the noise that can be created by the flapping of the material. If it is installed tight along the bottom of the rafter and not draped, then it might solve the noise problem. Using a housewrap seam tape along the rafters where it is being stapled would seal up the staple holes and eliminate any potential airflow in those areas.

Posted: 3:38 pm on October 29th

user-427606 user-427606 writes: In an application where I had a room in a roof structure I would describe as a half story I applied 1/2 inch foil foam board to the top side of the rafter with the foil side up over the insulation between the rafters. 5/4 batons on top of that with the roof sheathing attached the batons. Tapped the seams with foil vent tape. In this particular case the sheathing is ladder and the room material, metal. Air flow is excellent and the room is easy to heat and cool as never before. Curious if I could use the same setup under an asphalt roof material.
Posted: 5:54 am on October 29th

Log in or create a free account to post a comment.