previous
  • 13 Door Design and Installation Tips
    13 Door Design and Installation Tips
  • How it Works
    How it Works
  • Buyer's Guide to Decking
    Buyer's Guide to Decking
  • Painting Ideas, Tips, and Techniques for a Professional Finish
    Painting Ideas, Tips, and Techniques for a Professional Finish
  • Meet the Fine Homebuilding Project House!
    Meet the Fine Homebuilding Project House!
  • 15 Coffered Ceiling Design Ideas and Tips
    15 Coffered Ceiling Design Ideas and Tips
  • Guide to Paperless Drywall
    Guide to Paperless Drywall
  • 7 Solutions for Kitchen Layout and Design
    7 Solutions for Kitchen Layout and Design
  • Roofing articles, videos, tools, and materials
    Roofing articles, videos, tools, and materials
  • Outdoor Kitchen Design Inspiration
    Outdoor Kitchen Design Inspiration
  • The Inspector Game: Decking Dos and Don'ts
    The Inspector Game: Decking Dos and Don'ts
  • 10 Basement-Remodeling Tips and Techniques
    10 Basement-Remodeling Tips and Techniques
  • 7 Small Bathroom Floorplan Layouts
    7 Small Bathroom Floorplan Layouts
  • Energy-Smart Details
    Energy-Smart Details
  • 12 Remodeling Secrets Revealed
    12 Remodeling Secrets Revealed
  • Complete Kitchen and Bath Guide
    Complete Kitchen and Bath Guide
  • Fine Homebuilding: The Digital Issues
    Fine Homebuilding: The Digital Issues
  • 2012 HOUSES Awards
    2012 HOUSES Awards
  • Deck Design & Construction Showcase
    Deck Design & Construction Showcase
  • 9 Design Ideas & Tips for Concrete Countertops
    9 Design Ideas & Tips for Concrete Countertops
next

Better than Plumb

Better than Plumb


The quality of our decisions

comments (0) October 10th, 2008 in Blogs        
Kevini Kevin Ireton, editor-at-large
2 users recommend


 

Every day on my way to work, I drive past a stone wall in the town of Bridgewater. Actually, I drive past a lot of them; this is New England, after all. But I always look at this particular stone wall, and more specifically, at one particular stone. It’s a big round stone that anchors one end of the wall, where there’s an opening to pass through.

If you know anything about building stone walls, you know that stones with flat faces are much prized. Flat faces turned outward help to make a good-looking wall. Multiple flat faces make a stone easier to stack and easier to stack other stones on. Most prized of all are the stones with two flat faces perpendicular to one another. These you always save to make a corner, or an end. Round stones generally get broken or buried.

Not in this case, though. In this case, whoever built that stone wall placed a big round stone on the end, and then stacked smaller flat-faced stones on top of it. The whole arrangement looks awkward, precarious, and to my eye at least, absolutely striking. I can’t drive past without looking at that stone. I don’t honestly know if I love it or hate it.

I wonder who put that stone there, and I wonder why. Was it a bad decision made at the end of the day by a tired stonemason? Or was it a brilliant decision made by an artist consciously trying to thwart my expectation and capture my eye? Or (most likely) was it the only nearby stone big enough to anchor the wall?

I also look at that stone every day and wonder: Would I have put it there? Despite years of contemplating the question, I still don’t know the answer. I suspect that I would not have put the stone there because I’m too conservative. I also suspect that I forestall answering the question definitively because I’m reluctant to accept my own lack of daring.

That big round stone reminds me of a fundamental truth. We are all of us, to some extent at least, defined by our judgment. The decision to do one thing and not another, the reasons that underlie our choices, and the extent to which we let circumstances influence the choosing—those things say a lot about who we are, as builders or writers or human beings.


posted in: Blogs

Comments (0)

You must be logged in to post comments. Click here to login.