I am a carpenter of 30 years and am in the process of builoding a new home for my family. My problem lies in the fact that I have been continually confused by contradictory information about insulating techniques and vapor barriers. The Building Science website has been of little help to me because of what I consider confusing presentation. Some homes I have worked on in the past, the insulating contractors have used R11 glass and 1″ polyiso as a vapor barrier. Sloped cielings are R30 with propavent and 1″ polyiso as a barrier. Nowhere have I seen this practice mentioned (using polyiso as a barrier on the inside). Fire hazard is eliminated by drywall. Building Science only shows using polyiso as an exterrior sheathing. Does anyone use a similar practice (polyiso on the inside as a vapor barrier on walls and roof ?)
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
The best tool for straight, splinter-free cuts is made even better without a cord.
Featured Video
Builder’s Advocate: An Interview With ViewrailHighlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
yes, in jobs where higher levels of insulation were worth the price ( eg: electric heat ).. we use 1" high density EPS with furring on the INSIDE.. we used to use polyiso.. but it was not as cost effective as EPS.. and we use dens-pak cellulose behind the EPS... not fiberglass
Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
Yes, you are on the right track to doing it right. You have also wandered into the the wasteland laft behind after the last battle of the vent wars. As with the DMZ in Korea, it is an uneasy place to find yourself.
;)
Excellence is its own reward!
"The first rule is to keep an untroubled spirit.
The second is to look things in the face and know them for what they are."
--Marcus Aurelius
You might also want to get the Building Science Book for your climate. Or check with your local library.
The book has lots more details and options in it.
Yes we have used unfaced FG in the walls and ceilings and 1 in R Board inside with great success (west central Illinois). We use plywood or chipboard outside with Tyvek over that.
The CIPS energy consultant long ago advised us against visqueen under SR. He said he had learned this over 25 years before that.
I have heard other contractors talking about mildew and moisture problems here with visqueen. One job they removed the ceiling in order to remove the visqueen. My theory is that you can get almost instant condensation on visqueen. The R Board, however, will disperse the heat or cold on either side and you will have a hard time getting condensation droplets to form. This covering of all the wood really makes for dramatic results heating and cooling too.
Surely the climate makes a great difference on this, but my experience with visqueen as a vapor barrier is the exact opposite of what I have read in many articles, including FHB. I am NOT AN EXPERT in this field, but I won't be using VQ unless the customer insists at his own risk.
Here's what I would do if I was building a house here in midwestern Illinois as far as insulation: R13 unfaced fibreglass in walls. plywood or chipboard outside with Tyvek over. Inside 1 in R Board with 5/8 SR over. Ceilings: 5/8 SR, 1 in R Board, 12 in fibreglass unfaced. Ridge and soffet vents with Proper Vents. What's wrong with this anybody?
you mean besides the fiberglass ?Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
What is your suggestion about the fibreglass?
don't use it.. it is impossible to get a draft tight fit in any bay... switch your specs over to dens-pak cellulose...we used to use all fiberglass in the walls , and cells in the attics..
we switched over to 100% cells about 3 years ago..
here's a link to the system we use..
http://www.regalind.com/technical.htm..
other than the fiberglass, we use a lot of the same techniques you list.. with one exception.. in the wall system, we horizonatally strap the walls at 16" OC..we use 4" sq. elec. boxes with a 1.5" plaster collar
Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
".we use 4" sq. elec. boxes with a 1.5" plaster collar"
Are those available in bigger versions? What do you do at say a door where you might want 2-4 switches.
1st... in the exterior walls is the only place we do this... so.. we try to keep the device boxes to just what we need.. if an alternate location makes sense.. we get it out of the exterior wall..
i'll have to go back and look at what we did for ganging so i can give you the real answerMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
Would you mind explaining the strapping. I can think of some things, but I may be missing the point. Thanks
putting 1" or 2" foam ( we use EPS Performguard ) on the interior presents a couple of problems.. most have to do with there being no nail base behind the sheetrock / blueboard..
if you furr your walls , you eliminate those problems & you gain a couple of things..
(1) you can blow dens-pak cellulose behind the foam and it won't blow the foam off the wall
(2) you gain another 3/4 " of space BEHIND the elec. devices .. space for insulation..
(3) you have a nailbase for trim around doors, built-ins , baseboard & molding
(4) you have a better surface for hanging your drywall / blueboard without crushing the foamboardMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
Mike,
Looking for alternative techniques for the same buildng methods...how do you detail cells in rafter bays with regards to ventiing the underside of the sheathing? Manufacturered baffles? What do you use that stands up to DP cells?
Thanks, Mongo
Mongo, we use Propa-vent .. one of those closed cell egg carton type baffles..
here's one view of the upper roof.. the baffle only extends a comfortable distance past the cell fill mark ( in this case 24" ).. so the upper roof of this gambrel will have cells 12" deep and tapering up to 24" then leveling off over the balance of the attic space..
the 2d view is at the plate line on the lower roof. here we use 2x8 rafters to get more insulation room... the thinnest point will be at the upper plate ... about 6".
at the base we dropped a vertical plywood back wall ( knee wall ) so we can get about 16" at the floor level..
if this had been one of our energy houses, and we were trying to maximize the R-values.. we'd add 1" or 2" EPS foam to the interior face of the rafters and stud walls before we furred it.. in this case.. we'll concentrate on a lot of attic insulation...Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
Thanks for the reply and the pics. Are those baffles strong enough to not be crushed by dense-packing cells in a closed rafter bay?
Thanks again.
yes, absolutely.. they get stapled on the 3 flanges, Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
shows it pretty clearly on inside face of studs in heating climates.
http://www.buildingscience.com/housesthatwork/
scroll down & select your climate. Joe is among the first to promote outer face vapor barrier & sealed attics in cooling climates.. but I find that his "science" is pretty good - lots of sources & real world research cited throughout.
(When I lived & worked in SC - up til 9/02 - I was told by mechanical contractors that Joe is a nut. Supposedly some building science professor at Clemson refuted his work but I could NEVER get them to share any facts or written opinion. Since my in-laws are all Clemson grads, I guess I just have to go with JOE!)