Really ugly, and large, plain brick face on the old fireplace. The mantle is lovely though. I would like to cover the brick with something, but am undecided about what finish I’d ultimately like. For a fireplace, what is the best substrate to accept most finish materials?
thanks-
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story

The crew discusses finding rot when remodeling, challenges installing custom shower panels, and how to prevent subs and suppliers from sabotaging builds.
Featured Video
How to Install Exterior Window TrimHighlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
The substrate all depends on the finish materials. In a working fireplace all combustible materials must be keep a certain distance away from the firebox, I dont recall the exact distance right now.
right- i'm aware of that much.I'm wondering what fireproof materials would be available for different jobs; ie, if i want to do tile, what would I mount to the brick? If I want wood panelling to match my trim, what would I use under that to protect the wood? And would there be one I might use in an all-purpose application, that would take tile but which i might also be able to cover with wood panels?
If you want to do ceramic or stone tile, you need to use a bonding agent on the brick, then the thinset. If you're worried about an uneven surface, you could parge the brick face as an interim coat.You also mention wood paneling or trim. Note that combustibles must be kept at least 12" away from the opening (last time I checked anyway), so you'll need to either leave some of the brick uncovered, or you'll need to use a non-combustible material for those areas (all three of them, right, left, and above the opening)A remodel that I'm working on has a walkout basement that will be a sort of mother-in-law suite. It had a 1970-style brick wall, with a brick hearth and a fireplace. It now has drywall, a wood mantle and front-piece, with granite that will match the kitchenette counters as the "surround".I don't know if granite is a good idea in this situation or not -- the HO didn't ask me, and I don't know if he asked anyone else. But the granite sales/installation guys told the HO "no problem".As for mounting the non-combustibles.....mortar works. Mounting the wood paneling or mantlepiece involves nailers that are mounted with anchors into the brick.
Politics is the antithesis of problem solving.
i don't know what "parge" means, but i had it in my mind that i would probably cover the entire thing with some sort of non-flamable sheet material (using screws and adhesive?), then tile or panel over that, with your 12 surround around the opening.
Hey we have a similar situation with a bunch of plain and ugly brick with no real design concept. 70's house. My plan is to use HardieBacker to help provide a flat surface more easily tiled than parged brick. We are leaning towards 3/8' granite 12x12 tiles surrounding the woodstove insert with a wood mantle surround around the tiled opening set back far enough for fire code restrictions. I'm thinking 8" wide is enough for the tile on the sides, but the height above the firebox or in our case the wood insert is very specific depending on the projection out from the wall. In our situation I think it is about 48" above the hearth. All this needs to be doublechecked. All of the work is pretty easy the real trick is, as it usually is, to get the proportions, design and the materials to work together.
With an insert it seems obvious to lay the granite and let the insert or glass doors overlay the stone tiles. The wood surround usually overlays the tile, marble or stone on the outside.
That was our plan, but we got sidetracked with more urgent projects. Still need to check if hardibacker is acceptably noncombustible. If not I would guess cement board is probably okay, you would have to check. I used Hardibacker under a kitchen tile floor and liked it pretty well. It seems easier to me as an amateur tiler if the subsurface is flat and level. A granite place told me that they use a high temperature construction adhesive (without the backer board) I would go that route if I was going to use granite scraps, say 3/4 X 8 x 36" for the side uprights with a 3/4 x8 header across the top and supported by the sides.
These are just a couple ideas. Lots of examples in magazines, including some very good designs for wood surrounds also called fireplace fronts or mantles. Folks use these terms differently across the country. A person could cover the brick entirely with tile or granite, but it might seem pretty overwhelming or cold and boxy. At least ours would. A combination of Wood, with tile or stone, and glass doors or an insert offers lots of design possibilities. It can be a focal point or just be understated and right whatever you want. The wood surround covers the outside edges of the tiles and can be anchored in many ways. They are sometimes mounted with fasteners that are concealed with trim, pilasters, crown mould etc. and usually have returns scribed back to the wall on either side.
Hope this helps. Bob
Thanks for the info. Is cement board the same stuff as the "diamond board" (used in my last bath reno under new tile floor)? I figured that it would definitely work, but didn't know it it would be overkill or if there are other products out there ideal for this.FYI, in my case I am not looking to make the fireplace look "updated"; I just want it to look like a better quality job done vintage-style, ca 1922. Around here, they are usually tile, wood, or cast iron. I'm busy with a kitchen reno and haven't thought much about what look i want on the fireplace, i just know it needs to be something else.
Edited 12/16/2008 11:24 pm ET by RalphWicklund
>>"i don't know what "parge" means, but ...."It means that you add a layer of mortar to the face of the brick, troweling it in place to a reasonably smooth surface. Parging is commonly done inside the smoke-shelf area of a chimney, sometimes on the outside of foundation walls.If you want to cover the face with non-combustible sheet goods, then fire-rated drywall is one option. Another might be Hardie backer. I'd have to research whether or not the perma-base backers would be OK, since they use a plastic foam aggregate -- it might not be NON-combustible.You also need to think of the fastening method for the sheet goods. The fasteners must also be fireproof. Tapcons come to mind -- Lowes has them.
Politics is the antithesis of problem solving.
You may want to take a look here at least for some ideas
http://jerongmarble.com/show_fireplacemantels.asp?cat_id=58
wood and stone might be a bit fancy for some tastes but there prices are not too bad.
Wallyo
I had a similar problem -- ugly brick fireplace. Solved it by screwing diamond lath to the brick, and mortaring on some sandstone that I had cut to about 1-1/2" thick. We really like the results. Here's a pic of My Lovely Assistant tapping the final stone home. The plywood you see is a mock-up of the mantle that was installed later -- acted as sort of a form for the stonework.
View Image
Mike Hennessy
Pittsburgh, PA
Thanks for all the advice and photos!FYI, the original wood mantle is fine, though shallow, and continues around the adjacent walls as the top of built-in bookcases flanking the fireplace; I don't want to rip it out or replace it. the problem is going to be doing a "thin" treatment, so i don't bulk out the FP too much.I'll post photos in a few days- my 7-yr old son built me a "retreat" right in front of it that he's very proud of and it's a bit hard to see right now :-) In the meantime, I'm thinking that the best way to keep the new face from bulging too far out from where the mantle starts would be to do some thin wood trim (veneer that matches the mantle) over the substrate for a few inches, then some sort of molding to finish it off, over the tile or other treatment I use. Will try to sketch it out and scan for your consideration later-Thanks again!
You can't just post a teaser like that and not follow up....where's the pic of the completed project?
J. D. Reynolds
Home Improvements
LOL!
Who cares about the completed project? It's all about the JOURNEY, Grasshopper!
Serially, I didn't have a more recent snap on my PC. So I just took one. Lousy lighting, but you'll get the idea. Quilted & curley cherry, finished with shellac, thank you very much Frenchy! ;-)
View Image
Mike HennessyPittsburgh, PA
Absolutely gorgeous.....great wok Sensai!
J. D. Reynolds
Home Improvements
"Absolutely gorgeous....."
Thanks, but compared to what was there before, anything would be geee-orgious. ;-)
Mike HennessyPittsburgh, PA
I just installed a mantle in my home and used granite for the face closest to the firebox. Because of the size of the peices, I got them pretty cheack form the broken slab pile. I good heavy duty adhesive should be all you need to attach the peices, if you install them as two "legs" covered by the third. That way most of the weight is downforce. Just brace them agaisnt the mantle until the adhesive sets up.