I am using Hardie backerboard on the floor and they recommend their brand of 11/4″ screws with a square drive. These are very good screws however, they do not fit my “stand up” driver extension. The heads are slightly larger than deck screws. Since I have a large amount of board to lay I would like to use my drill extension. Has anyone used regular drywall screws or some other substitue for the “recommended” backer board screws?
Thanks in advance for your help.
Gene Sullivan
Replies
Don't use drywall screws. Not strong enough (some will snap) and because they don't have the fins on the back of the head to make them countersink into the CBU, they won't be flush with the surface of the hardie. DAMHIKT. Another brand that I've used for this is called Rock-On, but it too may have a wide/big head.
The square drive is there for a reason, easier to drive these babies in without camming/slipping.
http://www.pamfast.com/screws/screws.html
Some cement bd recommended screws from PAM.
Will your gun accept the PAM plastic collating strip?
Remodeling Contractor just outside the Glass City.
Quittin' Time
I have tried using deck screws on occassion, but ended up wishing I had not. Ditto on the nibs under the heads ... it sure makes it easy to get the screws flush. And I found that the CB screws with the philips heads tend to either snap off the bit or wallow out the recess much easier than the square drive ones.
"When asked if you can do something, tell'em "Why certainly I can", then get busy and find a way to do it." T. Roosevelt
I am no expert, but I have read up on all this for a tile installation we're doing.
Everybody is right about drywall screws.
I don't think you necessarily need to use the square drive screws from Hardie, but you should use a screw that is is specifically designed for cement board. We ended up using some off the shelf screws from Menards that had a Phillips head.
********************************************************
"It is what we learn after we think we know it all, that counts."
John Wooden 1910-
I think the backerboard screws suck. I use galvinized nails.The main reason I use nails is that the screws sometime reverse thread on me and actually lift up the backer board during the last quarter inch of travel. Often they do not seat flush either. Nails are cheaper and more predictable."I may be drunk, but you're crazy, and I'll be sober tomorrow." WC Fields, "Its a Gift" 1934
I'm with Scooter, if you have a lot to do, get a roofing gun with galv. nails and it is sooooo much quicker. Remember to offset your corners and try not to land a seam on a joist. Also your 3 x 5 sheets should go perpendicular to your 4 x 8 plywood subfloor. Use alkali resistant mesh tape for your joints.
I usually use torx-drive "gold-diggers" (general purpose/deck) for cement board and hardie board under tile. They sink flush better than those with big heads and are stronger than sheetrock screws. Locally these are becoming very popular for a multitude of purposes that need a bit more strength and ease of driving than sr screws.
Of course a company will recomend their own proprietary brand of screws!
I would too...
Quality deck screws work great, The problems with the stand up gun in what scoot said about lifting.
How much floor do you have?
Put some knee pads on and a bucket of screws and go to town on it, the knee pressure helps hold down the board and you can see easier if it lifts or causes a bump, Nails work too but I have seen some pops on a 2nd floor (long span) so your call, Hardi screws work great but you have gravity helping you. Save the 'spensive hardi screws for the tub surround.
I hand nail gal roofing nails.
Jeff
Buck Construction
Artistry In Carpentry
Pittsburgh Pa