I’ve seen where radiant floor heating is placed in the basement slab pour over top of 2″ rigid insulation. What is the practice without infloor heating? Not too long ago saw in FHB, 1″ rigid insulation placed on top of slab then plywood subfloor ontop of that. Is it better to go on top or under slab? I’m guessing in the article it could have been a reno job leaving above slab as only option. what do people do in new construction?
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
Fine Homebuilding's editorial director has some fun news to share.
Highlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
It depends on where you live. I'm building some slab on grade houses right now and installed a 2' strip of rigid foam around the perimeter only. This is what is required by NC code. This is pretty much what is done with basements too, although if the basement slab is, say 6' below grade, obviously, the need for insulation is greatly diminished - unless you live in Alaska ;-)
Re installing rigid insulation on top of the slab, you would end up with a much more "user friendly" floor. The added expense would have to be taken into consideration though. I'd estimate roughly $1000 per 1000 sq feet for materials only.
Whatever you do, don't forget the poly under the slab though. It is essential and keeps moisture from coming up through the concrete.
"Whatever you do, don't forget the poly under the slab though. It is essential and keeps moisture from coming up through the concrete."
That leads me to another question. I was looking at some laminate flooring recently and it specified a vapour barrier on top of concrete, below the underlay. would that be redundant? or is it a good idea?
PS what do you mean by user friendly? do you mean that it will create a buffer from hard concrete?
Edited 7/24/2005 11:01 pm ET by 1fred
In this case redundant is OK. The laminate manufacturer (nor some homeowners) have no way of knowing if there is a VB under the slab. So, if there is, VB on top of the slab is a cheap insurance policy.
User Friendly = hard and potentially cold concrete and damp concrete converted to a soft stepping wood floor. For example, a hard concrete floor makes one's feet tired after a number of hours, and the dull thud sound that your kid's head makes when he trips and falls is rather disconcerting.
The extra layers will cost a bit of sometimes valuable head room though. Matt
most builders do not insulate basement slabs.... think it's a waste of time and money
we always insulate basement slabs with 2" EPS, treated with borates ( PerformGuard ), under the slab on top of a 12" crushed stone bed ( high water tables ) with internal drains to daylight or to a sump
Mike:I know that you're located in the northeast. So when you insulate your slab homes, is the 2" foam board:
1) totally covering the floor or just 2 ft in from the perimeter?
2) covered with poly before pouring?
Rookie
it's under the whole floor...
we used to use the 6 mil poly.. but our studies show that the eps will retard vapor.... and the 2" thickness is strong enough to withstand abuse during the pour..
assuming it's installed on well graded and compacted gravel baseMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
Hello Mike, I live in Montville CT and am about to pour in the next 2 weeks, and I wanted to know if you tape the seams of the EPS boards and do you use wire mesh or fibermesh in your basement slabs?
Thank you, Bigman (Dave)
big... we use 2" EPS and under slabs we order 2 lb/cf density..
we get it from Branch River Foam in Smithfield, RI... 2" ( and 2lb. density ) is strong enough to pour on and walk on without breaking up ..
we don't tape the joints.. but we do put about one inch of sand on top to give it some protection and absorb some of the bleed water...
we use 12" of 3/4" stone under our slabs with a 4" perf-pipe around the border either leading to daylight or a sump.. this pipe system also has risers to provide for future radon mitigation if needed..
the foam goes right on top of the well graded stone
we use 4" of 3000 # 3/4" stone mix with no WWM or fibermesh..
watch the jobsite water adds and pour a stiff mix with just enough water to work Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
Hey Mike, I spoke with Ed at Branch River Foam and he said that I dont need the 2" 2lb foam board, to use the 2" 1lb. he said it was just as rugged and that it was being used under slabs at the "Big Dig" without any breakage problems. I need 3600 Sq Ft and with the 2" 1lb at .17/board ft vs 2" 2lb at .35/bf I could use the $1260.00 elsewhere in my project. Are there any particular reasons you use the 2lb? and do you think I should use poly under the foam, over the gravel?
Thanks
I used 2 1/2" thick, R-10, 1# EPS foam from Branch River under 6" concrete for a radiant floor heated airplane hangar I did recently in New Hampshire. About 3,000 sq. ft. Handling the one pound foam was no problem, and it was half as much as the two pound. The 4x16 foot panels go down quickly with fewer edges to contend with than the typical 4x8. The issue is not with the load bearing with the concrete placed and cured, it is the durability when your concrete guys are working on it. I think the 1# is plenty durable, and your concrete men can't be a rougher bunch than mine!
Put 6 mil poly under the foam to keep the water out of the foam. 1# EPS with borates is a much better deal than the standard 2# XPS foam.
I used Rcontrol type II I think they call it. It's one pound, about half the price.
Same advice from the salesman, it's the guys walking on it that will do the damage.
Joe H
well, bigman... there you go... consensus says.. save your money..
ask your concrete guys to have mercy....
i was used to the higher compressive strengths of Foam-ul-R & Styro -SM, so when i switched over to EPS, i was looking for more of the same..
i forget what the compressive strength of the 1 lb/cf is..
i do think the 2" board is strong enough for the walking by the placement guys as long as there are no voids under the foam.. and they are careful on the edgesMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
Funny how there can be big differences of opinion on some of these topics. I just poured a garage floor, using 2" of 1# EPS on the advice of a friend who also is a manufacturer of the stuff (and gave me a good deal).
Over on the Doityourself.com forum under garages, the topic came up, I mentioned what I had used, and got a couple very adamant responses that I should have used the XPS, due to its higher strength, higher R-value, and lower water absorption.
It's too early to tell with mine - it's only been 3 weeks and I've yet to put any serious weight on it, as I'm building walls right now. Seems like the EPS should be adequate, however.
Don
yeah, well, i used to be a big advocate of XPS... not any more..
EPS for me...Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore
I ran across the numbers at one time.IIRC even the 1 lb stuff is good for 7 psi, that works out to 1000 lb/sq ft.And with concrete you have 100% contact.The only problem with the lighter weight stuff is possible damage befor/during the pour.
Bill,
I think the number I saw for the 1# was 10 psi. However, I believe I also saw a note that that value is based on 10% compression, which would be .200" for a 2" thick base. That's a lot of movement for concrete. I think though that with good compaction underneath, a well poured and cured slab with some reinforcing, that I'd always have the load spread out enough that I'd never come close to that kind of pressure & deflection.
Don
Just poured my garage/shop and basement with 2" of 1.5# EPS under both. 6 mil poly on top of the foam as a VB because the EPS is somewhat permeable and the VB should be on the warm side. Seams in the poly were well overlapped but not taped. WWM in the basement with a few 1/2" bars thrown in to hold it up against the abuse of the concrete finishers' feet, and 1/2" bars 12" OC for my shop. I sawed pieces of backer brick from a chimney we demo'd to use as chairs- lots of bearing area and nice and smooth so it didn't tear the poly.
So you can split the difference and go with 1.5#. I bought it at a good price from Amvic when I bought my ICFs. It's plenty durable enough to survive the pour. Just make sure your stone base is very well levelled.