I’m looking into getting a router and as with most tools, there are too many features and options to make it easy to choose.
What are the advantages / disadvantages of Fixed base and Plunge routers?
Why not have a plunge router….can’t it be used as a fixed base router once you set the depth and lock it?
So far if I had to choose, I would get the Dewalt, 2 HP variable speed plunge router.
Any suggestions? My first project is to mortise a door for hinges and detailing molding. Most of the projects I have in mind could be done with a fixed base, but I figure that it will come in handy in the future.
Thanks!
Replies
You can buy a kit that comes with 2 different bases. The plunge router base can be bulky sometimes, and it's nice to have the plain fixed base.
I'd choose Bosch View Image, or Porter Cable View Image over Dewalt.
--------------------------
It's only satisfying if you eat it.
Edited 2/8/2006 6:31 pm ET by dustinf
This has been asked recently. I have the Bosch 1617EVS kit with both a plunge router base and a fixed base. Its 21/4 horse and the only complaint most have is, if you use the tool in a table the power switch gets clogged with sawdust and needs to be cleaned out so you can turn the thing on.
BTW, would I buy it again? Yes as a matter of fact I did when I was ripped off this summer.
I figured that this question has been asked a number of times....I searched the breaktime several times but came up with either too broad of answers or none at all.
Thanks for the imput!
I figured you figured that. Just wanted to give you the concencus of that post (at least through my eyes).
I like a smaller router for mortising and simple round overs. A large router can be a little top heavy.
we have 10 or more routers in our shop and truck, our favourite for most uses?
the porter cable 690 series, i think we have 3 of them
powerful, easy bit change, lots of accessories
a plunge base is a nice addition to a basic tool, but a fixed base is all that is needed for most jobs and the pc base is really easy to adjust for depth
Hey JaySun,
did you make your choice?
I use the PC 310 for routing strike plate mortises along with other doorlatch hardware. I have a DeWalt trimmer set up to fit into my Bosch Hinge mortise jig with the collar in place. I have three big routers, Milwaukee, PC and DeWalt, and the 690 with fixed and plunge bases. Just got the DeWalt for a portable router table set-up I'm using tomorrow on a door trim-out job.
I love the PC 310 for mortising. The 690 is great for all around. I use the Milwaukee in a router table, and works great for that. I use the big PC for production use...but I imagine the DW 625 will get some of that use, as well. I would direct you to the following website...I found it straightforward and honest. I have no relationship to the site or the author. Good Luck.
http://www.patwarner.com/selecting_router.html
"The nearest thing to eternal life we will ever see on this earth is a governmental program" -Ronald Reagan
Great Site.
As with most things, there are too many choices, options and accessories.
I did choose a router. I went with the Bosch 2 1/4 HP Fixed base and Plunge base kit with 1/4 and 1/2 " collets. Variable speed. I was able to get a factory refurbished model for $159.99. Shopping around it seems to be a good price.
Now I'd like to find a good set of plans for a router table.
Thanks!
keep us posted on how many times you change bases
i have alot of routers and usually use the smallest one when i can just because it is light
but i have a very cheap black and decker it is great for weaving cedar shingle corners
"but i have a very cheap black and decker it is great for weaving cedar shingle corners"sounds like a good way to trim the shingles, i'll have to remember that.
what type of bit, 1/4" with a bearing on the bottom?Erich
1/2" flush trim bit yes bearing on the bottom works great
I know its a little late to reply, but I just watched an episode of New Yankee Workshop where Norm basically did a Router 101 show. I recorded it (TiVo) for secondary viewing.
It may be too late to catch the New Yankee Workshop, but maybe someone can recommend a good resource, whether it be online or book or etc... for router knowledge.
Once I'm finished with my custom door and trim projects, I'll be looking to find more projects for the Router. I'd like to make some simple cabinetry. Possibly making the boxes and buying the doors.