Has anyone ripped 3/4″ MDO into battens for machining by either a router or moulder for use as moulding? What would be the pros and cons instead of using solid wood for this purpose?
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
The FHB Podcast crew takes a closer look at an interesting roof.
Highlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
Are you sure that you mean MDO???
That is a plywood with oaper overlay. I dson't think plywood would make a very good wood for milling like that.
Did you mean MDF which is a fibreboard ?
We mill a lot of our own trim stock from Poplar. One of my subs built a house for his own customer and he used MDF through-out. He liked theend product, but found that it burned up the bits and blades really fast. There are resins and bits of trash - staples, grit, etc, in the MDF and a different density thn natural wood.
Subsequent reseaarch ( partly here - and I think in the sister forum Knots) taught us that the blades for the milling machine are cut at a different pitch for MDF thaan for wood in order to last. Not being willing to make the investment to regrind all of my blades, I have not purssued using MDF.
I hate the dust from it anyways.
There are some advantages to MDF but not enough to outweigh the disadvantages, IMO
Welcome to the
Taunton University of Knowledge FHB Campus at Breaktime.
where ...
Excellence is its own reward!
Yes, I do mean MDO. Recently, I made a mailbox from the material and was impressed with the consistency of the interior plies. I didn't see any voids. That's what gave me the idea.
I know others have used MDF to similar purposes, i.e., raised panels, etc. but I'm hesitant to use MDF because of the possiblity of the machined edges degrading over time.
Thanks for your reply.
well, then definitely stay away from MDO for moldings. It will splinter too much. The core is fir
Welcome to the Taunton University of Knowledge FHB Campus at Breaktime. where ... Excellence is its own reward!
Received a lot of helpful comments.
Thanks
Piffin
You'd know more about this then I, but couldnt he run Azek or some of the other manufactured "plastic" stuff for trim? I dont buy the stuff so I dont know what it costs. I do know that it can be profiled. I also dont know what it'd do to the cutters, probably not nearly as much as what MDO or MDF does.
I wouldnt even think of putting a profile on MDO, cant see where that would turn out good.
Doug
Yeah, I definitely would never use MDO except for signage.Cabinetmaker/college woodworking instructor. Cape Breton, Nova Scotia.
Azek is very easy to mill, doesn't bother the cutters at all.It does mill up with a somewhat furry finish though that needs sanding. I've use it quite a bit around showers and in bathrooom/kitchens as paint grade replacement for wood.But the cost is close to astrnomical. There are some offsets in that there is no waste, but he did mention cost was a concern for him.But it looks like he is in Hawaii and that somehow really skews the csts for various products. Maybe the stuff from china is cheaper and the stuf from NewHampshire is more expensive, so it might depend whether there is an Azek knock-off plant nearby
Welcome to the Taunton University of Knowledge FHB Campus at Breaktime. where ... Excellence is its own reward!
EVERYTHING in Alohaland is more expensive just for the shipping and energy costs. I would also imagine that the tropical humidity must play a part in material selection. I wonder how well MDF does there?
The only thing Azak does to the blades is create a buildup of residue plastic after some use. I take a few minutes and clean it with a razor.
Pretty good chance of voids in the core plys. Unlike Baltic Birch which is not as likely to have them.
Finishing the edges would suck, and I'd bet router bits would dull rapidly from the huge amount of glue, which can be abrasive in nature.
Now, just rips for say, battens or backer for dentil/crown pack out, might be an option.
I'd not do it..there are plenty of better choices, IMO.
Please see my reply to Piffin. I know some router bit mfrs cut their bits for different materials so that might be a solution to the glue problem.
My only experience with MDO comes from cutting a single sheet of the material.
Thanks.
If it were me to do, I'd glue size it on the exposed edges..Titebond III and sand, prime, sand,prime, sand, paint.
That fir end grain is wicked hard to get smooth with a router that is even close to dull, and if you "burnish" with a dull bit, the primer/paint will swell everything out of proportion. The edge grain will fatten out, while the end grain plies do not..you'll get steps in the profile.
That is all fine for outdoor signage ( of which I have made plenty) but for trim that you may actuall touch or see from less than 10' away...it depends.
Have fun.
Appreciate your comments
I'm pretty sure you must mean MDF like Piffin said which is a fiberboard and used quite a lot in making moldings.
I have replaced 75% of all the ugly clamshell casing trim in my house with my own milled out version of a beaded edged flat, and have used nothing but MDF. It mills good, but as mentioned above is very messy and dulls your blades fast. The reason I used it was because of the price. I had a lot to do and I probably paid an eighth of what I would have for poplar. The other good thing about it is that there's no seasonal movement. Once it's in place it stays put.
It's not the greatest stuff in the world to work with, it has a bit of a learning curve. I much prefer wood, but the price was really worth it to me.
I don't have that much more to do and I think I am going to treat myself to having a local mill shop do the rest.
I don't think there is mucch of a diffeerence in price for me, but the advantage my guy was going for is to eliminate that seasonal movement.I simple beaded edge would be easy enough to do. Most of our work skins the whole surface for the style of casings we do, so I guess it would matter what style he has in mind.And I would not mind throwing away/replacing fifty dollar router bits as much as regrinding $250 blades for my Williams and Hussey
Welcome to the Taunton University of Knowledge FHB Campus at Breaktime. where ... Excellence is its own reward!
I agree with the others....MDO wouldn't be a good material for mouldings, even rips as the edges would be exposed. MDF is a better product. I think MDF makes excellent mouldings in many situations, but I rarely make my own now.....I use a company that specialises in it: full 3/4" or thicker (I don't use the thin stuff), and they use moulding grade MDF which is very different from the usual stuff....more consistent. Regular MDF has slightly coarser particles towards the centre which are exposed when the profile is cut....moulding grade is consistent all the way through. I find not all MDF moulding companies are the same....the good ones are very particular about their MDF, the others buy on price.
I can get nice profiles, long lengths (12 footers are a pain in my home shop; 8 footers available also for standing trim), and it comes double-primed and ready to install. That's the way to go if you want MDF mouldings, IMO.
Cabinetmaker/college woodworking instructor. Cape Breton, Nova Scotia.
A $250 W&H blade? YIKES! One of my planer blades broke and they won't sell me just one and I thought those were expensive.
"Even if embryonic stem cells are absolutely good for nothing at all how can anyone in good conscience be against using them for research given that they are going to be destroyed anyway"? J.Hayes
http://www.john-lennon.com/imagine-neilyoung.ra
http://WWW.CLIFFORDRENOVATIONS.COM
You mentioned price on your project and that's what got me started thinking about using MDO. For example, 1x2 unmachined stock of poplar runs about $1.10/LF (in Honolulu) compared to $0.27/LF for the ripped MDO. Quite a substantial savings.
My upcoming project will require hundreds of LF. The budget is a high concern.
Thanks.
In my area, MDO is generally used for making signage etc. for outdoor use. I don't imagine there would be a problem making trim out it. I'm just a little old fashioned I suppose. I like good old fashioned wood. I'm funny that way.
Dave