Thank you all for your input on Andersen 200 vs. 400 double hungs. We have since learned a few things and now have additional decisions to make. Here’s what happened:
FIrst, we learned that the 200 Series did not come in just the right size and would require lots of drywall, wallpaper, etc repair on the interior (approx 30 windows). This would add to the $$ and hassle significantly.
Then, we learned that the 400 Series created egress issues. It seems you need a screwdriver to fully remove the sash, which given our sizes, makes them unacceptable for bedrooms.
The new option is sash replacements. If our existing frames and sills are in good shape, what concerns should we have when considering good quality replacement sash kits?
Must admit we got used to the idea of completely new windows, so we feel like we might be shorting ourselves by going this route… But my head also tells me that a good replacement will still put us far ahead of where we are today (leaky old single pane double hungs).
THX!
Replies
Old double hungs reglazed, with good storm windows and seal around all the moulding works very well. And you'll never get the look of authentic double hung windows with replacements. Adams makes nice original style storms.
I missed part 1 of the discussion, but have you looked in to Marvin? They make retrofit sashes & inserts.
> If our existing frames and sills are in good shape, what concerns should we have when considering good quality replacement sash kits?
First consider what shape your existing sash are in. Are they crumbling into fragments from termites and rot, or merely falling apart? If they're falling apart, but the parts are solid, you're much better off to take them apart, clean up the parts, and put them back together. If you have to replace some of the parts, that may also be worth doing. While you're at it, give them proper weatherstripping, which you can get from:
http://www.conservationtechnology.com
-- J.S.