Our utility company was in the process of upgrading 50+ year old poles and highlines when they knocked on the door. Crew foreman said to “turn off” elecrical items (not unplug) like the TV, computer, etc., as they were tying in the new highlines. Thirty minutes later, power was turned off on the whole power line. When the power came back on, the TV made a hissing sound and when we tried to turn it back on, it was dead. No amount of reset buttons, checking plugs for tripped breakers would change it. The TV manual said it had its own surge protection… I built a cyclone dust collection system with twin 220v General Electric motors. I bought the remote controls known as “The Long Ranger”…it’s been great until that same time and day. Now those are both dead… Each being 220v, how do you buy a surge protector for a standard 30 amp circuit or one for each blower motor with those odd 20amp rated plugs? When they replaced the step-down transformer, because of the hiss, I unplugged the TV, but unknowningly it must have been too late. When the power was cut to the house when the new pole mounted transformer replaced the 30 year old one that had several black drips on one side. I’ve contacted the electric Co-op and they have sent the paperwork, and the TV repairman has been here only to find the whole power supply is dead and a new on has to be ordered… He left a $250.00 bill for his first visit…and said the new part will arrive here at the house and to set his return appointment when it arrives. Except on the TV and the wireless remotes for the dust collector, I have surge protection on everything else, including the garage opener. Have you had any trouble like this? How was it resolved? Bill
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
The "She Build" initiative is empowering women in Seattle, WA by ensuring they have safe, healthy homes.
Featured Video
How to Install Exterior Window TrimHighlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
A surge protector doesn't
A surge protector doesn't protect against overvoltage from the PoCo. Do you know if something the PoCo did caused your problem? Have they admitted to anything?
What I do know is that the electric company had a subcontractor doing the work. Also, when the new 3phase lines were up and "Hot", they were replacing the old pole transformer with the black drippings going to my home. The fellow in the basket had a wireless yellow meter he held up near the new powerlines and said, "Whew! It's a wobbly 600."
The office personnel said that "Power surges are usually prevented by the pole transformer."
That last comment seemed rather opposite from when we had a power outage several years ago. We had several long "blinks" of no power scattered throughout a late afternoon and into the late evening, so I called to report them and understand what was going on. The emergency personnel answering the after-hours said that the crew was trying to get another leg tied back into the grid, but it kept throwing that leg's breaker. She said, "If I were you, I would turn off all your electrical applances and leave one 100watt bulb turned on. That way you will know when the power comes on."
What does that tell you?
The TV operates on 220V?
No, the TV was hit with a power surge and it's built-in protection failed. It's the 220v wireless remotes for the 220v dust collector's two motors that got hit, too. It seems anything that had a remote, but not on a protector got zapped.
I can easily find surge protection for the 110v, but what works for the 220v wall plugs the controllers plug into?
A whole-house surge protector. Mounts at the main service panel.
Be protected.
When power is going up and down it's wise to turn off unused appliances since things like brief power drops and undervoltage can damage many different kinds of equipment. (You'd be amazed at how many electronic devices can be damaged by turning the power off for precisely the "right" duration and then back on.) In addition, every time power cycles the various motors and other large inductive loads nearby generate voltage surges.
"A surge protector doesn't
"A surge protector doesn't protect against overvoltage from the PoCo."
Umm, that's what a surge protector DOES do - protect against surges e.g. overvoltage.
There are various kinds of surge supressors available that install at the service panel or meter location. However, many of them are expensive and may not be all that effective.
The most cost-effective approach, in my experience, is the whole-house surge suppressor that installs at the service panel and looks like a large plastic capacitor. They cost less than $50 and are very effective.
Surge protectors only kick in at several hundred volts (300-500V for a standard unit). PoCo-induced over-voltage incidents are generally only 50-100% over line voltage, and thus not enough to trigger a surge protector. And even if they do trigger, the protector will likely burn out before the voltage transient is over, so nothing is "protected".
"Surge protectors only kick in at several hundred volts (300-500V for a standard unit). PoCo-induced over-voltage incidents are generally only 50-100% over line voltage, and thus not enough to trigger a surge protector. And even if they do trigger, the protector will likely burn out before the voltage transient is over, so nothing is "protected"."
Not sure what you have in mind when you say "surge suppressor", but many or most devices sold as "surge suppressors" limit voltage to 125% of rated voltage in less than 1 nS. For example, this $23 surge suppressor limits voltage to 40V over nominal line voltage.
http://www.apc.com/products/resource/include/techspec_index.cfm?base_sku=NET7
Thus they can and do protect against the typical power line voltage fluctuations.
Some of the older surge suppressors did contain devices that would burn out if subjected to significant overvoltage for periods of minutes or longer, but that is almost unheard of in practice. In any event, a typical contemporary device can protect against 20Kv or more indefinitely. I'm not saying they couldn't ever burn out, just saying I have never seen one burned out, even after a near direct hit by lightning.
Pure and utter BS.
Mr. Bill, stay tuned for a DIY whole house protector engineered by Junkhound.
Be a couple months he said in a post lost somewhere in the old BT (just put in the message number in the search box) and it'll turn up.
Joe H