I have a 30 year old split level that had hardwood floors in the living and dining rooms of the main floor. I removed them due to heavy animal damage from the previous owner. The subfloors are in bad condition also. The plywood seems to be de-laminating, it is soft and un-level from sheet to sheet. I plan on installing 3/4 hardwood back into both rooms but need a solution before doing so. Would it make sense to remove the original subfloor to within a few inches of any walls and replace it with a quality grade tongue & groove product from the local home center? I want the best possible result and do not want to compromise.
If this is the best solution, are there any special details to be aware of?
Thanks for any possible insights!
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
Fine Homebuilding is excited to be the official media partner of the 2024 Building Science Symposium series! This event offers builders, tradesmen, architects, designers and suppliers to discuss topics ranging…
Featured Video
Builder’s Advocate: An Interview With ViewrailHighlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
How thick is the old subfloor.
Be sure you know the framing under those walls. Taking it to a couple inches of a wall may not leave you with enough framing to anchor the new ply and perhaps compromise the wall framing to floor joist connection (if any)
A great place for Information, Comraderie, and a sucker punch.
Remodeling Contractor just outside the Glass City.
Quittin' Time
Calvin-
Thanks for the feedback. The original plywood subfloor is about 5/8.
I was considering this option to keep the finished floor height relative to what it originally was especially with the transition to the kitchen floor. This is the only other room on the main floor and it is finished. I understand the concerns you mentioned. If you wouldn't mind, how would you tackle this project.Thanks.
Mark
Mark, How bad is the animal damage (stink)? I would defer a real answer until I saw the conditions. I would be hesitant to start removal without thinking through the alternatives like sealing the stink (if possible). How bad is the delamination?
You certainly could cut out alot, install blocking to re-seam the sheets and put down new. A great place for Information, Comraderie, and a sucker punch.
Remodeling Contractor just outside the Glass City.
Quittin' Time
Hey Calvin-
Honestly there are no side affects from the previous owners dogs with regard to the subfloor. When I bought the house, I removed the builder grade 3/8 pine flooring which was crap. The pine was stained, chewed and otherwise revealed the shortcomings of the subfloor.
The subfloor is delaminated in the corners where the sheets intersect and is otherwise soft and wavy. I'm sure it could be much better after a box of deck screws or something.
My thinking with replacing the ply with a 23/32 T&G product would be to create a strong stable base. A portion of the living room is a high traffic area. Within six feet you can go upstairs, downstairs, outside, enter the kitchen or the living room. My goal is to have a finished floor that looks great but is solid as a rock and could support a full size piano if needed.
What do you think?
What did the cheap pine feel like on top of that subfloor? If solid feel and no squeek is a goal, you might get by with screwing down the original. You know the potential problems cutting out vast portions of the sub floor. The slight differences in thickness could be dealt with I'm sure. Blocking of cut seams would have to be done right so there was no sponginess at their locations (blocks fastened to joists on perpendicular seams, backer strip with blocks fastened between joists for parallel seams-if not on a joist). Add wiring, ductwork etc and there's alot of work there.
This is one of those cases where I really would have to see the existing before I would advise on the repair. Having a good base to nail HW to certainly helps. A great place for Information, Comraderie, and a sucker punch.
Remodeling Contractor just outside the Glass City.
Quittin' Time
Ask the floor guy yo look at it and make an assesment for you.
I've never if rarely seen one as bad as you describe unless it was flooded, or they had a zoo in there.
Eric
[email protected]
It's Never Too Late To Become What You Might Have Been
I had the same problem in my first home. Pet urine that defied all attemps to clean or nutralize it over a 4 week period. I won't bore you with the ugly details. One hot, humid august day I came home from work and lost it, the smell had gotten WORSE. It was bare sub-floor at this point, with many cleanings and two coats of shellac and it was WORSE.
By the time my wife got home 2 hours later, you could stand in our kitchen and look thru 28' of floor joists, into the basement. Smell was gone.
Sealed the joists with 2 coats of shellac, did a little shimming to the top of the old joists while I had the chance, then glued and screwed 3/4" exterior ply down.
Never regretted the extra work or expense involved, everything from there on out was mint.
If your worried about any point loads, throw some blocking in while it's open and be done with it.
If I had done this to begin with I'd have easily saved myself 40 hours of work and agrivation.
Hope this helps, good luck...Buic
Buic:
I'm remodeling an older house that has 1/2 inch ply subfloor. I want to cut it out and glue and screw 3/4 sturdi-floor to make a solid base for tile. I'm worried about the wall connection to the subfloor at the edge. Did you cut the whole floor out up to the walls? Any Problems?
Thanks.
Yes, I cut the whole floor up, to within 2 or 3 inches of the walls. I had no problems from doing this. New floor was very solid.
There were a few spots that a knew would see a lot of traffic so I put some 2x4 blocking under the edge of the ply, between the floor joist. Probably was overkill, but hey.
By the way is your 1/2" sound and flat? If it is you might want to leave it and schmear a full layer of adhesive and screw the 3/4" on top of that. 1 1/4" of ply would make a heck of a base for tile. Just a thought...Buic
I'm gonna do it.
A question please. The original subfloor is 5/8 and the new will be 3/4 (23/32). Starting the new sub a few inches from the walls will leave a difference in height of 1/8 or so. How do you suggest compensating for this?
If you want to level out anything before the floor goes down, get a bag of dash patch, mix and apply as needed. While it's wet and fresh be sure to leave it flush and smooth. It's a real pain to scrape/sand after it's set.
Have fun...Buic
Wow Buic, I like it!I certainly don't mind the work and the expense is easily justified. I am also curious how close you cut to the walls. Are there any other tips or tricks you can offer?Thanks for sharing you thoughts.Mark
Mark - Yeah, one more tip, watch your step on the open joists!
Other then that it's really just a straight forward remove and replace type job...Buic