Bosch Model 1587AVSK
Bosch Model 1584AVSK
What’s the better tool handle grip or barrel? Does it all just come down to preference or is there an advantage to one or the other.
thx
cje
Bosch Model 1587AVSK
Bosch Model 1584AVSK
What’s the better tool handle grip or barrel? Does it all just come down to preference or is there an advantage to one or the other.
thx
cje
Few people understand it. Nobody agrees what it is, how to learn about it, or who's responsible for it. It has never been more important
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox
Fine Homebuilding
Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox
© 2024 Active Interest Media. All rights reserved.
Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox
Become a member and get instant access to thousands of videos, how-tos, tool reviews, and design features.
Start Your Free TrialStart your subscription today and save up to 70%
SubscribeGet complete site access to expert advice, how-to videos, Code Check, and more, plus the print magazine.
Already a member? Log in
Replies
I feel it is just personal preferance. I preffer top handle and trigger.
If you are thinking about making a purchase, you might want to check out the new 1590EVSK. I havent seen one yet - other than in magazines or catalogs, but, it is supposed to be the new and improved Bosch. Better blade change, more accurate, soft start, more constant speed. Think it is a lot heavier though. Just one more thing to look at.
Good luck,
Shoe
I've had the barrel grip for 10 yrs. Would not switch for anything..The only 2 problems with mine and it has seen some seriously hard use...the strain relief on the cord (where the hex key lives) has come out and the collar that holds it in is shot..and I lost one of the 'E' clips (a REAALLY tiny one) that holds the bearing blade backup..I wrapped a pc. of guitar string in the groove (3 yrs. ago) and twisted it and snipped it off..I was damn lucky to find the washer and bearing when it went south on me...GREAT SAW>>>...BTW when that happend I was notching galvanized area wells ...tough cutting.
I had the same e clip problem, went to the bosch shop and they wanted like 18$ for the guide and pin and e clip when all I needed was the clip. So X d that and went to the auto parts store(NAPA) and they had a nice assortment of E clips. Heck the guy just gave me 2, so that was a good deal. Plus now you know where to get em
Clay
heck, the guitar string been holdin for 3 yrs..why 'fix' it? I always carry short lengths in my wallet..just for such odd fixes.
I really couldn't get the e clips the way I like it real tight so good ol construction adhesive makes the clip stay put.
that would do it..I was thinking after the last post, buy another e clip and it would just come off like the first one..I re-string my guitars on a regular basis 4 at 6 strings , 1 at 12 strings, and a 5 string bass..got miles of old phos/ bronze..and nickel silver..NOW ya mention adhesive!!! <G>
CJEDEN,
I've always liked the barrel grip better,more control as far as I'm concerned. You're pushing right behind the blade instead of above the blade.
Vince Carbone
A great jigsaw, I have the barrel. And would do the same again.
Complaints? Yes, The saw no longer has the ability to make perpendicular cuts in thick material, or around curves.
Look at the new one before purchasing. And give the Festool jigsaw a good looking at. It seems to have everything and more and is very highly regarded.
Jake Gulick
[email protected]
CarriageHouse Design
Black Rock, CT
That's the blade or technique..if it saws perp. in a straight line, but not on a curve, you are doing it wrong or with a wrong blade for the radius..MAYBE the backup bearing is worn (or the blade is not tracking in it) if the base detent is engaged you ought to be square. And what amount of orbit are ya using on a tite curve?
I loaned it out (I know, I know.....) and when it finlly came back, it didn't seem the same. Slight bend to the plate, and the bearing is worn for sure. If I ever get a second to catch up, I'll either order a new one, or a bunch of parts.
I've tried it with lots of blades and in all orbit positions and no joy.Jake Gulick
[email protected]
CarriageHouse Design
Black Rock, CT
depends on what you're going to use it for- i have the top handle which probably gives me better control when using down-cutting blades in the finished side of laminates and veneers (it has a tendency to buck up out of the material so the top handle puts your hand right over the blade). otherwise, i've heard the barrel grip gives better control (don't know myself). the only knock i've heard on the barrel grips is that if you're doing a lot of cutting they can get a might hot to hold onto- you're basically holding the motor housing.
m
Thanks for all the advice--now I have to make a decision
cjeTake what you want, leave the rest
Another vote for the barrel.....your hand is lower, lower centre of gravity, more control IMO. The speed control thing doesn't bother me..... I can either speed up or slow down how fast I'm pushing, or it's no big deal to reach back and change the dial.cabinetmaker/college woodworking instructor. Cape Breton, N.S
Easy decision.... BOTH!
Who ever invented work didn't know how to fish....
Top handle you can control the speed by how much you squeeze the switch . Barrel grip you have to dial in the speed on the back of the motor. I find that I have much better control over the cut being able to feather the speed with my top handle than with my buddies barrel grip. .....My 2 cents..............Rik.............. Also see if you can find one with the steel case..........
Anbother vot for the barrel grip. I've had it for maybe 6 or 7 years now. Great for my large hands and great control with the steering wheel being low and behind the blade.
same tool ...
personal pref.
I have small hands ... forget if I was supposed to love or hate the barrel grip ...
I think "it's for big hands" ....
I love it .... feel I have more control .... and seems to cut "easier" to me ....
Jeff
Buck Construction Pittsburgh,PA
Artistry in Carpentry
I've got the "D" handle. Haven't actually used the barrel grip, but it seems like maneuvering the barrel with one hand and the blade knob with the other would be a little like patting your head while rubbing your tummy... Don't know that my coordination allows me to do that
99% of the time ... it's a one hand deal ....
just hold tight around the barrel .....
only for real up-close fussy work does the knob get touched ... and that's mainly to keep her from jumping around.
JeffBuck Construction Pittsburgh,PA
Artistry in Carpentry
I have an inline jigsaw by Bosch (discontinued). One of the best tools I've ever bought. Its like a little recip. Get's into tighter places, uses Bosch blades, lighter, plenty of power and good control. I use downcut blades in it to cut boxes into finised wood to prevent chipout and carbide grit blades in plaster walls.
I just had it repaired. Can't find a new one. If you find one, don't useit on plster or drywall ceilings. the dust gets down inside it and you'll have to get it repaired.
Electrical wiring is not a hobby!
"only for real up-close fussy work does the knob get touched ... and that's mainly to keep her from jumping around."
Ummmm...You are still talking about jigsaws, right??
Rich Beckman
Another day, another tool.
uhhhh .......... we were talking about jigsaw's?
Oh.
......
Yeah ...
it'll apply there too.
JeffBuck Construction Pittsburgh,PA
Artistry in Carpentry
I have both. It really is a matter of preference, so I gave the barrel saw to my son because I prefer the top handle. (The barrel saw was a $5 yard sale item that required $70 in parts to repair, but it was still a good buy.)
My only quibble is with the base plate. Mine is stamped steel and easily bent as well as knocked out of alignment. But it's also running on 10 years old (give or take.)