Replies

1. 
   rdesigns | Oct 16, 2012 12:15pm | #1

   Yes

2. 
   [email protected] | Oct 16, 2012 07:47pm | #2

   Maybe

   Depends on a few things:

   1.)  The cost of your heat source.  The higher you cost the more it makes sense

   2.)  Is the lost heat captured in a usable way.  If the water heater is inside the heated space, and you live in a heating dominated climate, where you heat most months of the year, and any "heat loss" from the water heater is going to heating a space you would normally heat any way, then it makes less sense to shut one of the heaters down. 

   3.)  Is shutting one of them down, going to cause an long draw time before hot water is delivered?  If water costs are high, or water is in short supply, it makes less sense.  This can be overcome in part with a recirc loop, but then you have the heat loss from the loop to contend with. 

   Personally I'd look at trying to feed 1-1/2 baths, the kitchen, and utilites out of one heater, so the other could be shut down when there arent guests in the guest baths. 

   Another option would be instant heaters at the point of use. 

3. 
   DanH | Oct 16, 2012 09:52pm | #3

   It depends a lot on the type of water heaters used and the distances involved.  Highly insulated electric heaters are very low loss, and having one "idling" is pretty inexpensive.  Plus you lose heat (and waste water) if the hot water must be piped some distance from one to the other.