HI, I would like to talk to anyone who has added a basement room under an existing slab, by sawing an opening in the thin part of the slab and excavating underneath, then added a floor and walls, etc. It seems possible, but some questions I have: is the thin part of the slab strong enough to stand without the support of the soil underneath, or would it have to be reinforced/supported somehow? Will the excavation, even though it would not extend to the slab perimeter footings, disturb the support of the footings enough to cause foundation movement? Seems to me a separate exit to the outside would be needed in the interests of safety (I intend to use the space as storm protectionas well as storage).
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
A pro painter evaluates a variety of drywall sanders and dust collection systems for quality of finish, user fatigue, and more.
Highlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Fine Homebuilding Magazine
Fine Home Building
Follow
-
Fine Homebuilding
Dig into cutting-edge approaches and decades of proven solutions with total access to our experts and tradespeople.
Start Free Trial Now -
GBA Prime
Get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.
Start Free Trial Now
Replies
Randy,
Welcome to Breaktime!!
If you click on your name above (where it says "To: RandyR"), you will open your profile.
We would appreciate it if you could fill some of that in, especially where you are located!!
Thanks!
Also, you posted this thread in the wrong folder. This should probably be in Construction Techniques (but I don't think anyone would complain if it was in General Discussion. Please feel free to post again in one of those folders.
I'm not qualified to comment on what you are doing...but I suspect that someone will be asking if in fact we are talking about the slab your house sits on (sounds like it, but your not specific).
Rich Beckman
Another day, another tool.
you cannot do it, without the extra rebar in the slab itself to control brending and the extra thickness needed, it would fall in on you, also the footer would not be deep enough to suport the building. Now if you could jack the house and change the foundation that would work.
Unless you want to join the ranks of the Darwin Award recipients or just want to make people pancakes.
I disagree. I think it is possible to add a basement under a slab on grade house, and do it safely, and end up with a properly engineered structure. But it would be fabulously expensive, probably more than tearing the existing house down and starting over.
Just what correctional facility are you enrolled in? We may need to look at some soil samples. I understand Alcatraz is solid rock. Would'nt it be easier if someone baked you a cake with a file in it?
seriously though, it would be way more expensive than moving the house out of the way or building a new foundation next to the house then move the house onto it.
I do know someone who had a full 8 foot high cellar dug under half of his house. The finished area was about 24x30. The slab has to go to begin with. They excavated enough of the perimeter to pour a footing and lay about 10 feet of block wall at a time. After they had their outside perimeter foundation system in place they erected another block retaining wall down the center of the house and poured the basement floor. it was a lot of work back when labor was cheap!
I've put basements under "regular" houses but never one built on a slab. I'm sure it can be done but the cost would probably be astronomical. If you're really serious about this talk to a good structural engineer.
HI, I saw recently a web site where a man described a prefab storm shelter which was installed in his garage by sawing a rectangle out of the slab and excavating enough soil to set the shelter into the hole; it sat underneath his car when he parked it in the garage; sort of like a "grease pit" with a steel lid. This gave me the idea. I wondered, though, if they realized: if the car was in the garage and a storm hit, the car would have to be moved out of the garage before the shelter could be used.
Thanks for all the replies and ideas. I know this would be expensive. People in my area don't typically have basements, and few of the builders know how to build them, so I was afraid to try to build one. I sure wish I had one now, though.
See there is no profile info yet?
For what you want to do location is everything, soil type, drainage, etc.
As others mentioned having done, I've added basements under frame houses with crawl space, which is 'easy' compared to what you are suggesting. Your BIGGEST problem is that you are not just needing a 3 to 4 ft extra wall in the basement, you have the full 7 ft depth to go. If you do not know how to design for soil shear characteristics and retaining wall design (or unwilling to learn), I'd shy away from a full basement attempt. Without knowing your soil type, even a hole with new wood floor over the slab removed above to within 4ft of wall, and leaving 4 ft dirt embankment underneath during new basement wall pour may be very risky, as in sink hole.
What I was thinking of was removing the slab inside the under-stairs closet, where the basement stairs would have been anyway. I only needed about 8'X10' which would fit well within the space under the den; there would not be outside access, though. Also, I added profile info.
Oh well hell yer Cajun, go ahead and do it! 8)
Wrong, I may be redneck, but not Cajun (north Louisiana). Besides, anyone knows a Cajun can't have a basement, it would be full of water.
or GATOR!
but if a cajun had a basement full of water, he be making money as a crawfish farm
What's the difference between a coona$$ and a dumba$$ ? The Sabine River.
Ok, for those of you who don't get it, the Sabine separates Texas from Louisiana.
I'm sorry, I thought you wanted it done the right way.
Just a thought for you. It might be possible to hire a house mover to slide beams at critical points under the slab. The by supporting the slab you could dig out from under. You should consider the lumpiness of the slabs belly. Depending on the age of the house,the underbelly might be somewhat smooth due to insulation.
There is still a lot of caveats. Check with your city inspectors and see if anyone has tried the same. They may have some helpful ideas if approached on a good day. bring donuts.
Since nobody elese said it, I will, "Welcome to BT."
I'm thinking that your idea has some soundness, but not the intended execution. You will not enjoy excavating by 5 gallon bucket through the stairwell. No way no how (not having any stairs in the stairwell being amongst the least of your problems.
If we use your 8 x10 space as an example, you're stiull looking at 9' to 9'-6" of excavation. That's 720 to 760 cubic feet (about 27 yards of material), or more than 350 bucket-fulls. This does not include any backcutting or "angle of repose" cuttting required.
So, we get this hole made, now it will need about 2 yards of concrete for footings and slab, about 30-35 buckets worth, back down the hole. That's before getting to the walls. Oh, and we'll be needing rebar in the hole, too. Wrangling #4 & #5 bar in 120" lengths through the house and down in the hole does not sound fun.
Then, we have to get wall up. They could be block (probably have to be, to get back fill behind them, and to get pilasters to support the slab above). That mean geting mortar in quantity into the hole, down the narrow stair case opening.
Mind you, this is all happening in the very dark, likely damp (even in NawLous'ana) soil, in cramped muggy conditions. Oh, and because Murphy requires it, you will have a soil pipe, the main house water line, and at least one other utility right in the way to cope with, too.
That's why you may have gooten some "noise" in this thread. If you are really keen on this, do as was posted before, cut the entire "ceiling" of the proposed room out ahead of time. Probably ought to wall off the room the work is in from the rest of the house while you are at it. A "temporary" door for construction access will not go amiss, either.
That's sounding like a lot of work, though, isn't it? Yeah, a couple of week's worth--better than ten or more tunneling like it's the Great Escape, though.
Storm shelter does not need an exterior egress, per se. It ought to have it's own air supply, though.Occupational hazard of my occupation not being around (sorry Bubba)
"Since nobody elese said it, I will, 'Welcome to BT.'"So what am I?? Chopped liver???http://forums.taunton.com/tp-breaktime/messages?msg=52586.2Maybe you have me on ignore!!Rich BeckmanAnother day, another tool.
close guess...
Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in a pretty and well preserved body, but rather to skid in broadside, thoroughly used up, totally worn out, and loudly proclaiming
WOW!!! What a Ride!
"close guess..."OK, but if it's all the same to you, I'd rather not know how close.Thanks.:)Rich BeckmanAnother day, another tool.
Probably never read my signature line either
Welcome to the Taunton University of Knowledge FHB Campus at Breaktime. where ... Excellence is its own reward!
Maybe you have me on ignore!!
Nope, I don't; just clean missed it in your post. Mea culpa.Occupational hazard of my occupation not being around (sorry Bubba)
You really need to learn some things about the strengths (and weaknesses) of concrete before you do something really foolish there.
Very generally, concrete is great for compression loading but is very poor in tension. That's why slabs have rebar - the steel provides the tensile strength that the concrete doesn't have.
If you undercut an 8'x10' area under your slab, that portion of the slab has no underlying support (from the soil) and is totally dependent on the rebar to keep it from collapsing. In the words of Clint Eastwood......."Do you feel lucky?"
You should talk this over with a structural engineer and let them explain the hazards of your plan - as well as ways to safely do this. I'm sure that it can be done, but it will probably be expensive.
Maybe just save yourself some headache (literally) and a whole bunch of money by building an addition to your house and putting the safe room basement under that. Working from the bottom up is so much easier than working in the dark all hunched over waiting for the trickle of earth to become an avalanche.
Shhhh, He doesn't want Col Klink to know he's building it!
Welcome to the Taunton University of Knowledge FHB Campus at Breaktime. where ... Excellence is its own reward!
Ah HAH!
So that's why there was mention of 350 buckets of earth to move. One at a time, shaken out through the pants leg and shuffled into the dirt of the parade grounds.
If the basement must be under the existing slab, then rather than excavate through the slab and attempt to keep the weight above from falling and the earth from trickling down the sides of the pit, an external approach might be more feasible.
Pick a spot on the perimeter closest to the basement location and tunnel inward, building your shoring and then your footings and foundation walls as you go. Any weight above can be successfully supported if done incrementally as can preventing sideways collapsing of the tunnel walls. Think of it as a horizontal application of vertical slip forming.
Randy, just dig the room under the slab. Then, cut the slab the exact size of the room. Leave the four corners intact and get three buddies to simultaneously finish the corner cuts.
KABLAM! The slab falls into the hole and you have an instant poured floor on your new lower level roof!
Fill in the top with advanteck.
blueJust because you can, doesn't mean you should!
Warning! Be cautious when taking any framing advice from me. There are some in here who think I'm a hackmeister...they might be right! Of course, they might be wrong too!
Water and soils types would be first on my list of concerns to check out before starting. But if you have a lot of time on your hands, I don't see that it wouold necessarily cost you that much - but now if I were doing the work - it would cost an arm and a leg.
What kind of engineering? Doesn't sound liek a PE.
Welcome to the
Taunton University of Knowledge FHB Campus at Breaktime.
where ...
Excellence is its own reward!
Not civil; mechanical.
your spot on
you can do this easy as long as your not under a load berring wall simply excavate the dirt it should be decent dirt or your house is on piles second put a beam of wood or metal in the center of your room just for gigles your floor or celing for the basment slab should have rebar if it dosnt its old but no matter concreat does have some tinsle strength and shoring will eleviate this.
all these asshats claiming to be enginers and such need to go back to the basics of physics its not like you building under cardboard my bigest concern that deep is water but a simple sump pumped into your existing floor drain should work just dont over complicate it miners have been digging caves for a very long time so enginers hehehehe go figure out how to build a floating house
and just for giggles lets assume that the ground is baby crap why not just build shoring walls and shot creat using the dirt wall as your back forum not pretty on the back side but hey it works
........been there done that
Hey there the lion, The thread you are responding to is 11 years old...
...just for giggles.
Lol! You need to pay more attention. You're responding to a thread 11 years old. I expect that job is ready for a remodel by now.
How's it going,
I did this and how I did it, it was under the kitchen. The first thing I did was dug a hole a little smaller than a cubic yard under the corner of the house and filled it with cement and then 12' down the wall I started digging straight down past the foundation and when I had enough open space I tunneled a hole on each side and put an I beam going across before digging deeper I then set up an a frame above the hole with a habor freight wench with the buttons on it and I used a metal 4' round tub to put the dirt in and then I would dump that in a lawn mower tractor trailer anyway, by the second day I had a hole 12 'x12'x12' and started digging a footing all the way around put gravel and rebar and filled with cement then I used foam board and used it behind the center blocks which I dry stacked and every forth row I put cement till I was at the top then I added another I beam they were 10"x20' I put them in the center 6 ' appart and used a bottle jack to tightly press them under the slab but not too tight and added some wood for drywall and finally poured the floor added some stairs and cut a hole through the slab in the garage for access. That was twenty years ago and to my knowledge there hasn't been any issures. I just used basic building skills and for me it was a pretty simple project I'm sure there's other ways. I did run into the footing going across the garage that kinda worried me but I just blocked under it and it worked out. Good look an be careful.